Whatever the case, my canine family grew again a year after we got Sophie and Sadie. We found out about a Frenchie that was looking for a home because her owners were being forced out of their house to an apartment that did not accept animals. Sadly, this is a really common story these days with all of the home foreclosures and job loss.
We had recently seen a red mask Frenchie at a dog park and she looked like a smaller version of the one we had seen. They're less common than other colors of Frenchies and I love the mask look, like a mini mastiff. Since we would never go to a breeder, it was fate that brought this Frenchie in need of adoption into our path.
We met with her owners in a parking lot in the Central Valley, after exchanging many emails and phone calls. Immediately you could tell that the dog had been cared for and loved, and the woman was teary knowing that she was giving her up. We brought Sophie and Sadie with us, and since all of the dogs got along, we knew it was meant to be. She was in great health, and a happy and confident girl, so different from the situation that we had picked Sophie up from. She was so physically fit that her jumps at the park would attract an audience, especially if there was a hose involved. We decided to re-name her Penny, because of her beautiful copper coat. We felt so lucky to have found such a great sister for our other dogs, and the people were full of gratitude to us for giving her a great home.
So now we had 3 female dogs of relatively the same age in the house, and as happens in a pack, one dog emerges as dominant. Ours was Penny. She was fantastic with people, totally respectful of the cats, but she was constantly on guard with her two dog siblings. Sadie is an extremely submissive dog, and I have never seen her get in a skirmish with another dog, so she just worked around Penny's dominant behavior and engaged her in play, forming a bond between them. Sophie on the other hand got the brunt of Penny's alpha nature, finding herself growled at, snapped at, and in one unpleasant incident, even pinned to the ground by her throat. It was really upsetting to watch, especially since we had worked so hard to bring Sophie out of her shell, and I could see her regressing.
I worked with them for months, and watched every episode of The Dog Whisperer or It's Me or the Dog that I could find, trying to choose the best way to prevent and correct the behavior. Cesar Millan and Victoria Stillwell have two very different philosophies and styles, but there are common themes in both of their methods. What finally worked is that I had to watch their every move, and if her body language even suggested dominance over Sophie, I stepped in and put myself between them, or made a loud "Uh uh" sound to let her know that what she was doing, or about to do, was not acceptable. Let me tell you, it is exhausting to be glued to your dogs at every moment, looking for signs of aggression, but I sure learned a lot. Frenchies do this thing that is unique, and once you learn to spot it, you can prevent a lot of bad behavior. Right before they are about to strike, they get really still and really quiet. They might give a slight warning growl, but the key is that they are still like statues with their muscles taught and their eyes focused on their intended object. And then POW they launch themselves like bowling balls, and you see their true bulldog nature, which is that they don't stop and they don't let go until they have "won". This is why, in my opinion, it is important to stop the behavior before it starts.
I want to break here to talk about understanding the nature of a breed before adopting a dog, as this is an issue that is near and dear to my heart. Just because a dog has a cute appearance does not mean that it's going to automatically behave in a civilized manner, and Frenchies often fall victim to people who have no understanding of dogs or especially bulldog breeds, they just want something cute and funny at the end of their leash. Frenchies absolutely require a strong leader - meaning not strong in the physical sense, but one who will be unfailing in setting boundaries and working with them. They are as stubborn as they are smart, and while they want to please you, they do not usually deal with confrontation well, especially if it comes from a dog. And those little bodies are strong, forceful, and with a jaw that can clamp shut like a steel trap. On the other side of their nature, they are extremely needy of their human companions, and get really stressed if left alone too long. It's really no surprise that the #1 and #2 reasons I see Frenchies end up in rescue is 1/ they don't get along with other dogs and 2/ owners do not have enough time to give them.
OK, so back to my personal situation with my little pack. Penny has been with us about 10 months now, and everyone gets along great. She has learned to trust us and the other animals in our home, and that fighting is not allowed. The three of them have a wonderful play style that usually makes people stop and look at the park (usually the two Frenchies chasing Sadie). It's only on rare occasions that her old tendencies come out, but I don't feel like I have to have eyes on her every second like I used to. And Sophie now feels confident in her own home, the way she should.
Penny will always try to be the dominant dog, but as long as her behavior stays in check, we accept that. I believe that dogs are ok following a natural hierarchy among themselves, as long as they all accept that I am ultimately in charge. And at her core, she is a loving, loyal, sweet dog who reminds us to find joy and seize every day. Preferably not by the throat.